Liquid Plumr Vs. Drano – Which One Works Better On What?

If you’re a homeowner, you must be familiar with the struggles of cleaning and maintaining a drain. These drains are undoubtedly the dirtiest and stringiest things in your house. Whether it is your kitchen sink or toilet, a clogged drain can create an annoying situation.

If they are not cleaned for a longer time, they become clogged, spreading foul odor and bacteria. Almost every drain requires rigorous cleaning every six to eight months. But to do so, you must know which cleaner to use, especially if you’re stuck between the debacle of Liquid Plumr vs. Drano.

Chemical cleaners like Liquid Plumr can dissolve chemical obstructions, such as soap, as well as the majority of organic materials obstructing your drain. On the other hand, Drano is a gel-based drain product that quickly clears clogged drains and improves water flow. It is also sold separately as a foam-based cleanser.

Liquid Plumr Vs Drano

What You’ve Been Missing

Homemade Drain Cleaner Without Baking Soda
Toilet Water Rises then Slowly Drains

Liquid Plumr

Liquid Plumr(Check on Amazon) is produced by an American company named Clorox. It’s even rated as one of the top ten most popular Health and Household goods.

The product instantly clears fully blocked drains, thanks to its robust triple action strength. While emptying the gutters, the Pipe Guard capability coats your pipes to protect them from damage.

How Does Liquid Plumr Work?

Liquid Plumr’s formulation is triple-action. Sodium hypochlorite (often known as bleach) and sodium hydroxide (sometimes known as lye) are the two main active constituents in Liquid Plumr. 

Bleach reacts with lye and water when the drain cleaner is mixed with water. So the cleaner degrades and produces heat. The mixture passes through pipes and dislodges obstructions. Liquid Plumr takes about 15 minutes to prepare.

Drano

Drano(Check Price on Amazon) is a drain cleaner made by S.C. Johnson & Sons in the United States. Drano contains sodium silicate, liquid glass, and specific compounds that have been known to react with sodium silicate.

As a result, you may see a chemical reaction if you have used other pipe-cleaning products before using Drano. Because of the liquid-glass reaction, PVC pipes cannot handle Drano. If you have PVC pipe, avoid using Drano because it will do significant damage.

Some people dislike this one because of the mess it causes. However, the product is safe to use with most pipe materials and septic tanks.

How Does Drano work?

Sodium hydroxide is one of Drano’s vital active ingredients. It decomposes organic waste. Drano, unlike other solutions, contains aluminum shards, which help create a significant chemical reaction and heat. The breakdown process is accelerated by heat.

Lye combines with softened grease to form soap, which is then dissolved in hot water. It eventually reacts with metal, forming hydrogen bubbles as a result. These bubbles aid in the loosening of blockage particles. 

Drano starts a series of chemical reactions in a sequence, making it extremely strong.

Which One Should I Choose – Liquid Plumr Or Drano?

Although the two items are identical, you must choose which one to use for your drain blockage problem. 

Liquid-Plumber is a better choice if you need a safe cleaner for your pipes and everyday use. If you need a product for a specific purpose, like cleaning the kitchen sink, however, you should get Drano. 

Ingredients

Let’s take a look at the ingredients of both products.

Ingredients of Liquid Plumr are:

  • Water
  • Sodium Hypochlorite
  • Sodium Chloride
  • Sodium Xylene Sulfonate
  • Sodium Orthosilicate
  • Sodium Hydroxide
  • Cetyl Betaine
  • Potassium Iodide
  • Pigment Green 7

Elements of Drano are:

  • Water
  • Lauric Acid
  • Sodium Hypochlorite
  • Sodium Hydroxide
  • Polystyrene Polymer
  • Capric Acid
  • Amine Oxide
  • Sodium Silicate

Product Options

Let’s take a look at the product options both brands provide.

Liquid Plumr Products:

  • Liquid-Plumr Clog Destroyer Plus Urgent Clear
  • Liquid-Plumr Disposal and Drain Cleaner 
  • Liquid-Plumr Clog Destroyer Plus PipeGuard
  • Liquid-Plumr Industrial Strength Gel 
  • Liquid-Plumr Kitchen Clog Destroyer Gel
  • Liquid-Plumr Clog Destroyer Plus Foaming Clog Fighter
  • Liquid-Plumr Clog Destroyer Plus Double Impact Snake
  • Liquid-Plumr Clog Destroyer Plus Hair Clog Eliminator

Drano Products:

  • Drano Kitchen Granules
  • Drano Max Gel
  • Drano Kitchen Gel
  • Drano Liquid Drain Cleaner 
  • Drano Dual Force Foamer 
  • Drano Max Build-Up Remover
  • Drano Snake Plus
  • Drano Hair Buster Gel
  • Drano Advanced Septic Treatment

Which One Costs More?

When determining which product to buy, pricing can be a concerning factor. You can anticipate paying between $10-$40 per bottle for both types. The majority of the bottles can manage one to three clogs.

However, Liquid Plumer is a little bit more expensive than Drano. Buying in bulk is the most suitable way to gain the most bang for your buck. Multi-bottle sets and larger bottles are available from both companies.

Which One Works Better On What?

Liquid Plumr is more effective on both fully blocked and slow-moving drains. It dissolves filth, oil, hair, and grease faster and in less time than Drano. Unclog drains, protect pipes, deodorize, lessen, and prevent drain odors with this triple-action product. While unclogging drains, Pipe Guard Technology protects pipes with a repelling barrier. 

On the other hand, Drano works better on slow-moving clogs. And it appears to work slower than Liquid Plumr.

Similarities Between Both Products

Both products are the same when it comes to:

  • Safe for all pipes, waste disposals, and septic tanks. 
  • Both can be poured through standing water.
  • They both form a covering gel.
  • The chemical formula is almost the same.
  • They should not be used in toilet bowls.
  • Both assist in improving water flow.

Pros and Cons of Liquid Plumr

Pros

  • It is affordable and top-rated.
  • It is fast-acting and safe to use.
  • It can be used as a secondary treatment.
  • It is less thick.
  • It works better on fully clogged drains.

Cons

  • It is more toxic than Drano.
  • It is more expensive than Drano.

Pros Cons of using Drano

Pros

  • It is less toxic than Liquid Plumr and more eco-friendly.
  • It protects against corrosion.
  • It can dissolve the most stubborn clogs.
  • It works better on slow-moving clogs.

Cons

  • It can not be used as a secondary treatment.
  • It is 50% thicker than Liquid Plumr.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Which one is more toxic – Liquid Plumr Or Drano?

Liquid Plumr contains bleach, lye, and other chemicals that are designed to burn through drain clogs. These are some of the most toxic compounds on the planet. So, Liquid Plumr is highly toxic. And Drano is said to be less harmful than Liquid Plumr.

Which one is thicker – Liquid Plumr Or Drano?

Liquid Plumr is less thick. But Drano appears to be 50% thicker than Liquid Plumr.

Which one takes more time to clean – Liquid Plumr Or Drano?

Liquid Plumr takes approximately 15 minutes to clean your drain. On the other hand, Drano takes 15-30 minutes to get the same job done.

Final Words

In the battle between Liquid Plumr and Drano, the job of both products is the same: to clean your drains. But if you have to choose between them, we will suggest you go with Liquid Plumr. Though it is more expensive, it works best on fully clogged drains and gets results quicker than Drano.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *