The argument between Pine-sol vs Mr. Clean isn’t new. People buying their cleaning supplies always get stuck between these two and rightfully so. Both these brands are insanely popular among users. But what are the differences and similarities?
Pine-Sol and Mr. Clean differ vastly from each other in product variety, ingredients, and method of use. In comparison, they’re pretty similar when it comes to price and effectiveness.
Contents
Pine-Sol Vs Mr. Clean: Comparison Table
| Pine-Sol | Mr. Clean | |
| Product offerings | Multi-surface cleaners, wood furniture cleaner/polisher,floor cleaner | Multi-surface sprays, liquids, sponges, mops, magic erasers, toilet cleaners, microfiber cloths, etc. |
| Ammonia | No | No |
| Bleach | No | No |
| Not compatible with | Unfinished, unwaxed, or unsealed wooden floors, cars, aluminum, marble, or copper surfaces, dishes, and as a pet shampoo | Carpet, copper, and aluminum surfaces. |
| Disinfecting products | Pine-Sol Original | Mr. Clean Antibacterial Cleaner |
| Owned by | Clorox Company | Procter & Gamble |
Related
Pinalen Vs Pine Sol
Pine Sol vs Pine Glo
Pine-sol vs Lysol
Differences Between Pine-Sol and Mr. Clean
If you want to decide which brand to go with for cleaning supplies, the first thing to do is to compare the differences between them. The significant differences between these two brands are the product line, how are they used, and their ingredients.
Product Line
When you’re considering the variety of products, Mr. Clean will get an advantage over Pine-sol. The products offered by Pine-sol are limited. This brand is more concentrated on offering specific products.
If I am being exact, it’s basically a brand to consider when you want a surface cleaner. That being said, you won’t be getting variety when selecting Pine-sol. There are five multi-surface cleaners offered by this brand.
However, you will also find a wood furniture polish/cleaner and a floor cleaner from Pine-sol. But that’s all they offer.
Now, if we are talking about Mr. Clean, the product variety is impressive. This brand is not limited to surface cleaners. Along with multi-surface sprays, liquids, sponges, mops, magic erasers, toilet cleaners, microfiber cloths, etc.
So, if you want to get an entire package to get started with cleaning, I recommend considering Mr. Clean. You can get everything from the same brand.
How To Use
As you can guess, there are hardly any differences in the methods of using different cleaning products. However, when comparing Pine-sol vs Mr. Clean, you will certainly notice a few differences. I’m mentioning how to use both products so that you can get an idea about each of them.
Pine-Sole
For general cleaning, you will need to mix Pine-sol cleaner with water. Then, take a cloth and dip it in the mixture. Clean any surface you want by wiping it.
If you are cleaning asphalt tiles or rubber, you will have to rinse the surface afterward. And speaking of rinsing, you can use the cleaner directly too. When going for heavy-duty cleaning, you can use the product directly. However, you will have to rinse the surface instantly afterward.
If you are using the disinfector from Pine-sol, the method will be different. Note that this isn’t a surface cleaner and you will have to clean the surface before using the disinfecting product.
After removing dirt from the surface, use a sponge to wet the area with the disinfector. Do not mix it with water. Allow the liquid to sit there for about ten minutes before rinsing it off.
Mr. Clean
Now let’s talk about Mr. Clean. Note that the cleaning procedures do not vary significantly. If you’re disinfecting an area using Mr. Clean surface cleaner, you will have to remove dirt first. Then, apply the product to the area and let it sit for about ten minutes.
Now, use a damp cloth to wipe the area and you are good to go. Let’s talk about cleaning in general. Just like the Pin-sol product, you will have to mix Mr. Clean with water if you want to clean any surface.
The measurement will be one-fourth cup of the product for each gallon of water. Apply the mixture to the area using your preferred method and wait for the area to dry. Unlike Pine-sol, this doesn’t require wiping or rinsing.
If you’re going for heavy-duty cleaning, no need to mix water with the solution. Simply apply the product to the spot using a sponge, wipe the area, and then use lukewarm water to rinse. Allow the area to dry before finishing up.
Ingredients
Both products are chemical-based, so there isn’t any basic difference. However, when you look at the ingredients, the formula is not the same for both brands. This is, of course, an obvious thing because if the formulas were the same, they would practically be the same products.
None of these cleaning products are organic or plant-based. So, they do expose you to a certain level of danger. However, as long as you are using the right tools and working in a well-ventilated area, the risks dial down to a minimum.
If you take the Pine-sol Original, you will find ingredients including water, PEG/PPG Propylheptyl Ether, Glycolic Acid, C10-12 Alcohol Ethoxylates, Xanthan Gum, Sodium Secondary C13-18 Alkyl Sulfonate, Methoxyacetic Acid, Caramel, Sodium, Formic Acid, d-limonene, hexyl cinnamal, Acetophenone, Myrcene, and Fragrance.
In comparison, Mr. Clean Antibacterial Cleaner contains water, C9-11 Pareth, Sodium Carbonate, Sodium Hydroxide, Citric Acid, Pentasodium Pentetate, Benzisothiazolinone, Green 8, Acid Yellow 3, and Fragrance.
Similarities Between Pine-Sol Vs Mr. Clean
Despite all differences, there are a few similarities between these brands. If youare considering all aspects before selecting a preferred brand, you should be aware of the similarities too. So, let’s get started.
Price
Surprisingly enough, both brands are inexpensive. No matter which one you go for, you will be getting the worth of your money. The difference in prices does not vary significantly.
If you want to compare the prices, check the price per ounce for each cleaning product. This way, you will be able to figure out the specific differences between the prices.
But the bottom line is, that the price should not be a determining factor when comparing these two brands.
Effectiveness
There is no significant difference between the brands when it comes to effectiveness. As long as you’re using the right product for the right purpose, both are excellent.
Note that a disinfector and a cleaning product do not work the same way. Pine-sol and Mr. Clean offer both disinfecting liquids and multi-surface cleaner.
A wide range of customer bases has backed up the brands with their reviews. In the end, it comes down to user preference, especially for fragranced products.
If you like a particular fragrance, you can choose that one over other options, regardless of what brand the cleaner is from.
Final Words
In this Pine-sol vs Mr. Clean argument, there is no loser. Both cleaners are excellent in their work and both are chemical-based cleaners. If you want something safer, these aren’t the options for you. On the contrary, if you are into effective chemical cleaners that are also inexpensive, these are the ones you should be considering. As for which one to go for, evaluate the differences I have mentioned and pick the one that suits your necessity the most.